Where should I park?

There is parking on both sides of Elm Street to gain access to our bakery. If you prefer parking in a parking lot instead of parallel parking; you can gain access to the municipal parking lot from Elm St. At the corner of The Coop. Or you can gain access to the municipal parking lot from Main Street by taking Grove Street and then taking a left into the parking lot. Park your car and walk down the alley where Sudz City and Food Works is. Cross the street at the cross walk and walk down the street to our corner bakery. We appreciate each and every customer that comes in. Follow the bright pink cupcake sign!

Do you have cakes readily available?

Custom cake orders need to be ordered at least one week prior to the chosen pick up date. You can place an order by coming in to the bakery or emailing us at info@timothyjaysweets.com.

Do you have Gluten Free options?

Yes we do! We offer gluten free chocolate and vanilla cupcakes with an option of Marshmallow Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream, or Peanut Butter Buttercream. We also offer gluten free cookie options.

Do you have dairy free or vegan options?

We do not currently have dairy free or vegan options. But, keep an eye on our social media as this is where we announce new products coming out.

Instagram | Facebook

I have a food allergy. What should I know before ordering?

Timothy Jay Sweets makes every attempt to identify ingredients that may cause an allergic reaction for those with food allergies. However, there is always risk of contamination as in our kitchen we use ingredients such as milk, eggs, flour, almond extract, tree nuts, peanuts, and butter, etc. and although we have strict cross contamination policies, we cannot guarantee a total absence of these ingredients in our kitchen.

Please contact us with specific questions regarding your dietary restrictions.

How far in advance do I need to place my order?

We ask for a one week advance notice for custom orders.

If you have any further questions, please contact us

Phone: 508-581-4118

Email: info@timothyjaysweets.com

Store: 97 Elm St Millbury MA